Surcharges: When to Use Them, When to Avoid Them, and How to Get Them Right
With rising tariffs and inflation impacting supply chains, companies are looking for creative ways to protect margins without scaring off customers. Surcharges are increasingly part of the solution — when used wisely.
At their best, surcharges offer businesses a flexible way to manage temporary cost increases. They provide a way to stay nimble in volatile markets, without locking in permanent price hikes. But when applied poorly, they can create customer confusion, damage trust, and even spark legal challenges.
So, when do surcharges make sense, and how do you apply them without backlash?
The Strategic Value of Surcharges
One of the most common and accepted uses of surcharges is to recover costs tied to external shocks. Whether it’s fluctuating fuel prices, new tariffs, or regulatory compliance costs, many companies use surcharges to pass through these expenses transparently. Customers are typically more accepting when the charge is clearly linked to a specific cost and positioned as temporary.
Surcharges can also reflect added value when customers request premium services. Instead of raising prices across the board, businesses can give customers the option to pay more for convenience, customization, or speed.
Additionally, some surcharges are used to nudge customer behavior. These tend to be:
- Behavior-based fees (e.g., bank overdraft or airline change fees)
- Viewed as avoidable by customers
- Perceived as fairer than blanket price hikes
When Surcharges Go Wrong
Problems arise when surcharges feel hidden, vague, or unjustified. Lack of clarity leads to customer frustration — and in some cases, legal action. A well-known example involved restaurants in Washington, D.C. adding “service charges” without explanation, which led to double tipping and lawsuits.
Other times, businesses misuse surcharges as thinly veiled price hikes. A 2% “environmental fee” applied universally with no clear purpose often feels like a cash grab rather than a necessity.
Operational friction is another risk. For instance, adding credit card surcharges may push customers to pay by check, slowing down cash flow and creating more admin work. Even respected brands like Southwest Airlines faced backlash after adding bag fees that contradicted long-standing policies.
How to Get It Right
Thoughtful implementation is the difference between a smart pricing move and a customer relations disaster. Consider the following best practices:
- Communicate early: Give customers a heads-up before implementing a surcharge. If it’s triggered by a market event (like fuel prices), publish the criteria in advance.
- Ensure tech readiness: Your invoicing and payment systems must be able to process surcharges cleanly. Many companies discover gaps too late.
- Review contracts: Make sure your terms and conditions allow for surcharge flexibility. If not, you may have little legal recourse when customers push back.
Final Word
Surcharges can be a powerful lever — but only when used thoughtfully. When customers understand the “why,” and when businesses lay the groundwork ahead of time, surcharges can protect margins without compromising trust. But rushed or vague implementation can do real damage.
If you’re navigating these decisions now, we can help. At Blue Ridge Partners, we specialize in pricing strategy and revenue growth — and have worked with over 1,300 companies worldwide. Let’s talk about how to get this right for your business.
Contact us:
📧 [email protected]
